Are You My First? - Season 1 Part 1 (w/ Paul Mizzi)

Resident reality love show expert and not so virginal Paul Mizzi joins Sam to take a dive back into the Off Season with the first part of Hulu’s horny(ish) Are You My First? The first two catch up on Netflix docos and discuss the imminent return of Japanese reality hit The Boyfriend, then get stuck into all the chaos from the messy first five episodes of the season. Noah can’t make up his mind, bombshells can't stop entering the villa and sexy host Colton Underwood’s tits can't stop being on display. Stay tuned for part two next week.

Follow The Cringe is Real on Instagram, TikTok, YouTube & Bluesky. 

Chapters

• 0:00 Intro
• 0:28 VIRGINS!?
• 6:05 The Boyfriend Is Coming Back!
• 8:35 Netflix Docos
• 11:12 Are You My First? Season 1 Episodes 1-5 Recap